To sulfur or not to sulfur

Winemaking (Photo: How Stuff Works website)

Where I was educated in wine, sulfur dioxide was considered essential to quality winemaking.

We were taught that elemental sulfur had been used since ancient Roman times as a sterilant and preservative. It was and still is used widely to disinfect barrels and other vessels, to keep unwanted insects away from fresh grapes and juice, to prevent oxidation at both the juice and wine stages, and to keep out unwanted micro-organisms. Even ‘natural’ winemakers who eschew sulfur dioxide additions throughout the process usually relax their rule at bottling, which is when wine risks absorbing oxygen that may spoil it.

For quite a few years I’ve been tasting Australian ‘Preservative free’ or ‘No preservative added’ wines, and been impressed at how good and fresh these wines usually taste. They’re almost always reds: red wines have tannin and colour pigments that protect against oxidation. Unsulfured whites are usually brown in colour and smell and taste stale. If you don’t mind that, go for it.

The McLaren Vale area produces several excellent unsulfured reds: Yangarra, Battle of Bosworth and Inkwell have all impressed lately. None of them smelled at all aldehydic (acetaldehyde is the first sign of oxidation spoilage). I tasted a vertical of Bosworth’s Puritan unsulfured shiraz, back to 2010, and they seemed to be ageing normally (read my article here). How they fare in the long term remains to be seen.

But the wine that really turned my head was a chardonnay – a Corton-Charlemagne worth several hundred dollars a bottle, no less. It was a 2013 Domaine Ponsot which, according to my notes, was priced at AUD $835.

This was not only a superb wine, razor-sharp and crystalline in its flavours and aromas, it was as fresh as the proverbial daisy. It was three years old and sealed under Ponsot’s trademark closure, a synthetic Ardeaseal plug, which may or may not be significant.

Producers of unsulfured wines used to promote them as asthmatic-friendly. But I’m skeptical of making blanket statements about sulfur being dangerous to all asthmatics. I have several chronic asthmatics among my circle of friends and they all happily drink wine, including white wine (which usually has more sulfur dioxide than red). Others say SO2 in wine gives them headaches, but this is usually anecdotal.

The current trend towards low-input, minimal-intervention (did someone say natural?) wine is having many positive impacts on the conventional wine industry, and one is the questioning of some of the additions some winemakers have habitually made. If wine can be made without loss of quality by cutting back on or completely omitting sulfur dioxide, enzymes, acid and tannin additions, surely that’s a good thing.

As we seem to be seeing with the above-mentioned wines, just because our parents and grandparents did things one way, doesn’t mean it’s the only way.

Sulfur tips:

A general guide to sulfur dioxide (SO2) levels in wine (highest to lowest):

  • Sweet wines, especially very sweet wines (eg. Sauternes) and sweet wines in casks.
  • Sparkling wines.
  • Sweet fortified wines.
  • Dry white wines and dry rosés – the sweeter they are, the more SO2.
  • Dry red wines.
  • Organic wines: SO2 is permitted but maximum levels are lower.
  • NB. Cask (bag-in-box) wines contain more SO2 than the equivalent wine in a glass bottle.
  • SO2GO: I have it from credible sources that this product works. You sprinkle a few drops onto your glassful of wine and it’s supposed to nullify the SO2. The active ingredient is hydrogen peroxide, which is very safe in these quantities. SO2GO is recommended for people with sulfur allergies or sensitivities. It’s sold in many bottle shops.

*First published in Gourmet Traveller Wine magazine, June-July 2017.

 

5 thoughts on “To sulfur or not to sulfur”

  1. Kate Kriven says:

    Hi Huon, In recent years, I have developed an allergic reaction to sulphur and use Pure Wine Drops (as you know, I also work in the wine industry so it is very inconvenient as well as frustrating). I’ve found Champagne to be one of the lesser offenders along with aged reds. You mention sparkling wine being high in sulphur and my allergic reaction agrees with you, but not when it comes to Champagne. Would this be due to the ageing process that sulphur levels diminish? Cheers, Kate

  2. Mark Hubbard says:

    I think I’ve said on here before that some of the wineries producing Chardonnay in NZ seem to be high on sulphur: it has no ill effect on me, I just don’t enjoy the taste thus tend to steer clear of those.

  3. andrew petersen says:

    Hi
    ‘Others say SO2 in wine gives them headaches, but this is usually anecdotal’.

    I am sure this applies to others, but I don’t get a headache , I get a migranes shortly after lasting a day !
    I seem to handle dry whites better than reds , out of a bottle. However it seems more related to brand, eg penfolds or region, eg French wines , So my body can handle a certain percentage Thus I am a little conservative and stick to wine I have no problems eg Wynns Black Label Cab.

    I have read the Italian wine limit the percentage of SO2 in the bottle, or have a lower maximum than here, if there is one in Australia . Is this true ?

    I wish they would put the percentage of SO2 on the bottle as well as what else they put in !

    I have heard of SO2GO or similar, I hav not tried it, but how would it affect the enjoyment of the wine ?

    regards

    1. Huon Hooke
      Huon Hooke says:

      SO2GO shouldn’t affect your enjoyment of the wine at all. As for Italy having a low maximum SO2 level, I doubt it very much. Anyway, I’d expect their legislation is the same as that of other member countries of the European Union.
      Bad reactions to wine are a vexed issue because these reactions vary so much between individuals. For example, many people report that red wines affect them more than white, but you say you find the reverse. Each person has to work out their own sensitivities and act accordingly.

      1. Geoff Garratt says:

        Hi Huon. Hope you’re well!
        My wife developed a severe allergic reaction to sulphites/sulfites some years ago (that have seen her in hospital several times) and after a lot of research (being scared shiteless of losing my drinking partner) I buy a 3% bottle of peroxide from the pharmacy and dilute it with water by 10% in an eyedropper bottle(resulting in a 0.3% peroxide mix). A little less than a half-dropper squirt into a glass of wine(pours are usually about 200mls) converts the sulfites to harmless sulphates, usually with no perceptiple change to wine characters.. Slightly smaller dosage for fizz or fortified pours(given reduced pour sizings).
        I have seen the commercially available products but am scepticle as to whether they remain effective and stable given storage temperature changes and product age. There is also no data presented on the composition of those products.
        I store my mix in the fridge and carry it out with us in a small insulated wrap. I also only use distilled water to dilute the peroxide.
        Whatever works and my mix does.
        Regards
        Geoff

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *